Geometrical quantification of taste judgment in the case of Harunobu

 

   Koryusai on the left  Harunobu on the right


I found a work that imitate Harunobu's "Gojorei" by Koryusai, who is said to be a follower of Harunobu. 

 It is well known  that it is based on Harunobu's work [Gojounorei] .

It can be imagined that the kimono figure on the left was brought from somewhere and synthesized without changing the kimono figure on the right.

Musically speaking, the right and left kimonos are not made with the same scale.

It will be clear if I make arc model.

As all the parts are not made at the same time,

Koryusai could not adjust the harmony  and balance.

Early ukiyo-e painters shared patterns and  drew similar pictures.

Harunobu's artistry lies in how well it is structured.

All the curved lines are arcs 

and the circles of the arcs are limited.

the largest and the second largest circles make basic structure.

                  Harunobu [Gojourei]
                  Koryusai [Gojourei]

Let's take a look at the left person in Koryusai's paintings.

It is unstable because the largest blue circles which  make the basic structure are missing.

 The second-largest circles that make up the red arc look chaotic, as if the hoops  have come off.

The circular structure gives the arcs  balance effect.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

An AI robot with no artistic appreciation ability can mechanically select works that are harmonious and balanced.

Image
  My daily image search for Matisse's drawings reveals that  there is a mixture of casually drawn pieces and well-balanced pieces, but they are easily distinguishable with taste judgement. The latter type is often lithograph. Recently I found something a little unfamiliar.      Henri Matisse, Plate 153. Florilège des Amours de Ronsard, 1948 At first glance, their hairstyles are almost same and they are facing right but they are different in size. The two shapes are just barely on the right,  so it looks like Matisse is trying for best one profile, but if you look closely, it's a pretty well-balanced composition. I can guess that this to be carefully crafted.   Harmony can be achieved by using only arcs of a limited number of circles, and balance can be adjusted by bundling those circles together.  Only a limited number of artists who know about this technique are already using it.  Conversely, an AI robot without artistic appreciat...
Read more

Picasso "Female Nude with Arms Raised"　1907 in the Sainsbury Collection ; more interesting than Les Demoiselles D’Avignon

Image
In the previous blog "Cézanne, Seurat and Beardsley arrived at the same technique", I wrote two conditions of modern art from the level of formalism: Constructing with only arcs of a few circles of different sizes creates harmony. Then the circles can be used to create a balanced structure. 　    Picasso “Female Nude with Arms Raised” 　 1907 in the Sainsbury Collection    Picasso “Female Nude with Arms Raised” 　 arc-circle model According to the explanation of the museum that owns this work, it is a study for Les Demoiselles D'Avignon, But if you look at the work itself 、 this painting is more complete. Comments without a structural model don't make much sense.  The model reminds me of Seurat's "Study of Model".    Seurat "Study of the Model"    Seurat "Study of the Model" arc-circle model.
Read more